Stan Musial

July 9, 1957 – The 24th All-Star Game at St. Louis, Missouri

On July 9, 1957, the Major League Baseball All-Star Game was held at Sportman’s Park in St. Louis, Missouri, home of the National League St. Louis Cardinals.  Controversy surrounded the game as Cincinnati Reds’ fans stuffed the ballot box and sent all but one of their starting players to the 24th playing of the midseason exhibition game.  The Cincinnati Enquirer printed up pre-marked ballots for fans to send in; as a result, over half of the final vote tally originated from the Reds’ hometown.

New York Giant Willie Mays and Milwaukie Brave Hank Aaron were appointed by Commissioner Ford Frick to replace two Reds’ players.  Voting procedures changed as well – player selections were made by managers, players, and coaches until 1970, after which time fans were once again allowed to nominate their favorites.

Revenge was sweet as the American League team defeated the National League, 6-5, after an action-packed ninth inning which began with the AL team ahead 3-2.  In the top of the inning, a single,a  fumble, a sacrifice, another single and a double brought the score to 6-2 for the AL.  The NL followed with a walk, a triple, a wild pitch, a single and another walk, a strike out, another single, a runner out at third on a steal, and then a pinch hit caught in left-center. It wasn’t enough to overcome outstanding fielding by the American League stars, who were able to squeak out their second win in eight years.

The starting lineups:

American League
1. Harvey Kuenn, Tigers, SS
2. Nellie Fox, White Sox, 2B
3. Al Kaline, Tigers, RF
4. Mickey Mantle, Yankees, CF
5. Ted Williams, Red Sox, LF
6. Vic Wertz, Indians, 1B
7. Yogi Berra, Yankees, C
8. George Kell, Orioles, 3B
9. Jim Bunning, Tigers, P
Manager: Casey Stengel

National League
1. Johnny Temple, Reds, 2B
2. Hank Aaron, Braves, RF
3. Stan Musial, Cardinals, 1B
4. Willie Mays, Giants, CF
5. Ed Bailey, Reds, C
6. Frank Robinson, Reds, LF
7. Don Hoak, Reds, 3B
8. Roy McMillan, Reds, SS
9. Curt Simmons, Phillies, P
Manager: Walter Alston

Image Credit: Wikimedia Fair Use